The Begotten Son of God

The Begotten Son of God




Mohamad Mostafa Nassar

Twitter:@NassarMohamadMR

First let us watch this two minutes video demonstrating Sons by Tonnes in the Bible

One rather strange and insulting verse we find in the Bible is that of John 3:16, which reads:

16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. 

So as you can see, the verse says that God gave his begotten son, this is indeed strange, since begetting children is not an act done by God, because the word beget/begotten infers that this came about through sexual intercourse/ and OR a Physical Birth ( Evidence Jesus was born physically from him human mum Mary)

How he is a SPIRITUAL son and what the difference between him and all other sons by Tonnes in the Bible?

The word begotten that is used here is called monogenes {mon-og-en-ace’} in the Greek language. The basic definition of this word refers to daughters and sons in relation to their parents through sexual intercourse!

So basically when John 3:16 calls Jesus the only begotten son of God it actually means that God had sex and hence Jesus was begotten!

Lest a Christian claim I am twisting things, let us see the word ‘monogenes’ used again in the Bible, notice the context this time:

Hbr 11:17 By faith Abraham, when he was tried, offered up Isaac: and he that had received the promises offered up his only begotten [son],

So notice the word begotten (monogenes) is used here referring to Abraham’s son! So therefore as you can see, in context the word monogenes refers to a son of a father which is created through the sexual act between a man and a women. 

So there is no escaping the fact that word monogenes which means begotten refers to a son or daughter which is produced through sexual intercourse, as you saw in Hebrews 11:17 it says that Abraham gave his only BEGOTTEN son referring to Ishmael, hence this word begotten refers to children produced through a sexual act. So my question is this, does the God of John 3:16 have sex?!

This verse is an insult to God, and Christians must either get rid of this blasphemous verse, or they should change the wording, and Christians should have no problem in changing the wording since many words and whole chapters in the Bible have been altered, changed, or even deleted! So Christians should have no problem in making a simple word change, this will be something normal for the Bible!

And I end this article with a lovely verse from the Quran which refutes such insults by the Bible:

112.003
YUSUFALI: He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;

In Response to the above part of this article about Begotten, Some christains have responsed by stating the folliwng:

Hebrews 1:5

For unto which of the angels said he at any time, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee? And again, I will be to him a father, and he shall be to me a son?   

1 Corinthians 4:15

For though ye have ten thousand instructors in Christ yet have ye not many fathers: for in Christ Jesus, I have begotten you through the gospel.                                                                

1 Peter 1:3

Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, which according to his abundant mercy hath begotten us again unto a lively hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the    

Revelation 1:5

And from Jesus Christ, who is the faithful witness, and the first begotten of the dead, and the prince of the kings of the earth. Unto him that loved us and washed us from our sins in his own blood.

Muslim Response:

Christians usually will bring up the concept of reborn out of the spirit and reborn concept by quoting Biblical verses such as the following: –

1 John 5:18

We know that whosoever is born of God sinneth not; but he that is begotten of God keepeth himself, and that wicked one toucheth him not. 

1 John 5:18 is Practically a lie when it claims that We know that anyone born of God does not continue to sin; the One who was born of God keeps them safe, and the evil one cannot harm them

No one of those who claim to be borna again Christians stopped committing a sin and NONE of them is Perfect.

By the way the Bible claims sons by tones for God but how Jesus is a the Only BEGOTTEN son of God and why BEGOTTEN- Remember we Muslims do not believe he was born out of a physical relationship not we claim that Christians say that too.

But the Bible wording and description of it has sexual connotations- as we explained earlier in the article, word Begotten has physical dimension which is Birthing- and that is exactly what happened to Prophet Jesus as he was physically born out of Mary and coming down via her urine passage.

Not only the Bible claim that God has many sons including Satan a son of God (Job 1:6) but also claims that Jesus a Begotten son of God and David a Begotten son of God (Psalm 2:7)

Are all these sons being result of physical birth or spiritual birth?

Yes, we know Christians will say all those sons are result of spiritual birth, but how can you differentiate between the Begotten son and the non-begotten son?

We reiterate again that begotten has sexual and physical meaning, obviously in case of all those sons they are not result of sexual relationship. But word Begotten still implies physical aspect to it and to support that notion. The Physical birth of Jesus and being born out of the physical body of his mum Mary.

By the way would you still consider Satan was born spiritually from God (Job 1:6)?

David of course had human parents, yet he was described as begotten son of God (Psalm 2:7)

The Bible states that God is Unique, No one have seen God, how can you claim God give birth even if it is a spiritual one?

Even if it is a “Spiritual Birth” can you describe that Spiritual birth and what the difference between sons of God in terms of birth as per the Bible?

In Islam God is Unique, has no sons, no parents, no physical relatives, when a Muslim return to practise Islam we do not say he is a reborn again Muslim, we simply say he choose to return to the straight path by the blessings of God.

The problem with using words such as son of God or begotten son of God or reborn again out of the spirit etc. that it does open the door to misunderstanding of the pure meanings of God praise to him as a Unique, supreme, king of Kings and mixing it with human traits which is blasphemous.

God does not need to be human or die to forgive, in Islam he can forgive directly without all that problematic process in Christianity.

Why Christians see Jesus is not enough as a Prophet?

Why Jesus as a prophet and messenger of God is not enough for Christians, we know that you will say that the wages of sin is death, but the whole repentance process that eventually as accepted and led to heavens to sinners during Adam time and all Prophets before Jesus, never ever included believing in a triune God nor involved believing in a someone died on a cross on behalf of sinners at all.

Check here for more information about the repentance process from Adam and all Prophets Before Jesus here. All Prophets Before Jesus

In Islam God is Unique, supreme, above us all, does not need to be incarnated in any way shape of form. Incarnation of God is a pagan belief existed for centuries before Christianity.

God in Islam sustainer of everything and does not need sons to forgive. A God that can not forgive sins without dying for sins is not a God.

God in Islam does not give physical birth and usually we abstain from describing a practicing Muslim or a Muslim who start to abide by the teachings of Islam as a (reborn again) Muslim. Or use word begotten.

Those Christian terminology are problematic and opens the doors for associating partners or equals with God, which means polytheism which is the opposite of monotheism. Once you start to say that Jesus SHARES divinity with God that means you have made Jesus a God with God, well Jesus used to pray to the father, does that mean that Jesus was praying tom HIMSELF?

Br.Sami Zaatari

And indeed Allah Knows Best!

Daniel 7:13-14 Messiah Jesus God?

All Prophets Before Jesus

Paul The false Apostle of Satan

Does Psalm 2:7 refer to Jesus or King David?

The Crucifixion Hoax

The Resurrection Hoax, a Big Scam

Contradictions in the Resurrection of Jesus Accounts

Responding to Malicious accusations about Prophet Muhammed’s Marriages

Why Jesus did not save John the Baptist who baptised him and made him God or son of God from horrible death by beheading and why did not he bring him back to life?

Isaiah 9:6 Messiah God?

Isaiah 7:14, Immanuel: Prophecy of Jesus?

Unfulfilled Christian religious predictions

The folly things of God and Yahweh attributes described by Blasphemous Bible.

Bible: Yahweh Best of Deceivers?

I am the Lord God Dionysus : Parallels between Yahweh and Dionysus

Allah or YAHWEH is the deceiver!?

Allah as the Best of Deceivers? Between The Noble Quran and the Bible

Yahweh is Found all over the old testament BUT not once in the new testament, Why?

Yahweh is Found all over the old testament BUT not once in the new testament, Why?

How the Jews Invented Yahweh, and Made Him Great

Christian Scholars refuting the status of the NT as an inspired scripture

Did Jesus really forgive sins?  Or is this another trinity lie?

Let us create” in the book of Genesis: (Does “us” mean GOD and Jesus?)